x

Disulfiram vs Naltrexone: Which Alcohol Medication is Right For You?

Medically Reviewed by
Marisa Savic, PMHNP-BC
November 1, 2024

Medications like disulfiram (also known as Antabuse) and naltrexone can be strong tools to help you manage Alcohol Use Disorder (AUD) when prescribed as part of Medication-Assisted Treatment. These medications differ in their mechanisms of action, effects on alcohol consumption, and general side effects. Understanding these key differences before you start treatment can help you choose the option that’s best for you.

Disulfiram vs Naltrexone: First-line and Second-line Choice

Naltrexone (Vivitrol)

Naltrexone is widely regarded as the first-line medication of choice to treat alcohol use disorder. Approved by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for this specific purpose, naltrexone has garnered significant recognition for its efficacy in curbing alcohol cravings and reducing the pleasurable effects of drinking.

Quick facts about Naltrexone or Vivitrol for addiction treatment

Disulfiram (formerly Antabuse)

Disulfiram is considered a second-line option for individuals who do not respond well to naltrexone. While naltrexone reduces cravings and the enjoyment associated with drinking, disulfiram primarily acts as a deterrent to drinking due to the severe reactions that occur if alcohol is ingested while on the medication.

Quick facts about Disulfiram for alcoholism

Disulfiram vs Naltrexone: What MAT Alcohol Medications Do

How Does Naltrexone Work?

Naltrexone is classified as an “opioid antagonist”, meaning it blocks certain receptors in the brain called mu-opioid receptors. These receptors are involved in the pleasure and reward system of the brain. When someone drinks alcohol or uses opioids, these substances activate the mu-opioid receptors, leading to feelings of euphoria or a “high”. Naltrexone binds to these receptors and prevents them from being activated.

If a person consumes alcohol or opioids while on naltrexone, they won’t feel the usual pleasurable effects, and cravings will decrease.

How does Disulfiram work?

When you drink alcohol, your body breaks it down into a chemical called acetaldehyde. Disulfiram blocks the enzyme that normally breaks down this chemical. If you drink alcohol while on disulfiram, this chemical will build up on your body and cause unpleasant symptoms like flushing, nausea, vomiting, headaches, dizziness, and chest pain. This is known as the “disulfiram-alcohol reaction”. The effects of disulfiram can last for up to 2 weeks after your last dose.

Formulations of Disulfiram vs Naltrexone

Naltrexone is available in two formulations, catering to individual preferences and treatment needs. Disulfiram is available in oral tablet form. Both medications are prescription-only.

Disulfiram Tablets

Disulfiram tablets typically come in 250 mg doses. They are usually administered once daily. It’s highly recommended that disulfiram be taken under supervision, whether by a healthcare professional or a trusted family member. This practice enhances accountability and ensures adherence, as the disulfiram-alcohol reaction can be severe and potentially life-threatening if alcohol is consumed while taking the medication.

Naltrexone Tablets

The oral tablet form can be taken daily or on an as-needed basis, a practice known as “targeted naltrexone,” which allows individuals to strategically take the medication before high-risk situations or events where heavy drinking may occur. Naltrexone tablets typically come in 50 mg doses.

Injectable Naltrexone (Vivitrol)

Naltrexone is also available as a 380 mg long-acting injectable (Vivitrol). This form is administered by a healthcare professional every four weeks, offering a convenient alternative for those who may struggle with daily adherence.

Side Effects of Disulfiram vs Naltrexone

As with any pharmacological intervention, both disulfiram and naltrexone carry the potential for side effects. While most side effects are mild, serious side effects can occur, particularly if a patient has certain co-occurring conditions. Before starting either treatment, inform your doctor about your medical history and any medication you might be taking.

Disulfiram: Potential Side Effects and Precautions

Common side effects associated with disulfiram include:

  • numbness or tingling in the extremities
  • skin irritation
  • Headaches
  • fatigue.

More serious concerns involve the risk of liver damage, which can manifest as jaundice, abdominal pain, nausea, and dark urine. Individuals with severe heart conditions or psychotic disorders may be advised to avoid disulfiram altogether.

Naltrexone: Opioid Interactions and Liver Monitoring

While generally well-tolerated, naltrexone can cause side effects such as:

  • Nausea
  • Headaches
  • Dizziness
  • restlessness.

Injection site reactions may occur with the long-acting formulation (Vivitrol). Naltrexone should be avoided in individuals currently taking opioid medications or experiencing opioid withdrawal symptoms, as it can precipitate severe withdrawal reactions. Liver function monitoring may be necessary, particularly at higher doses of naltrexone.

Marisa Savic, PMHNP-BC

Marisa Savic, PMHNP-BC is a board certified psychiatric mental health nurse practitioner who received her nursing and master’s degrees at the University of Pennsylvania. Marisa has worked as a provider, clinical manager, director of clinical quality, and program manager of addiction treatment at numerous companies specializing in telepsychiatry as well as working in person at inpatient, outpatient, detoxification and crisis center facilities. She is currently the National Lead Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner at Eleanor Health and her clinical interests include therapeutic communication, evidence-based treatment and nonjudgmental care.

Medication Guide Addiction & recovery Blog

Related Articles

A addiction treatment counselor conducts a virtual treatment session Virtual Addiction Treatment: is it as Effective as In-Person Treatment?
In an increasingly digital world, virtual care options offer a new path forward for...
Read More
A person puts their hand on a friend's shoulder in support of their addiction recovery journey How to Stop Alcohol Drinking Safely: The Journey Towards Recovery
Alcohol addiction, also known as alcoholism or alcohol use disorder (AUD), is a chronic and...
Read More
Two people look at a laptop to see if online rehab is covered by insurance Does Insurance Cover Online Rehab and Medication-Assisted Treatment?
As telehealth services, including online addiction treatment services, have become more...
Read More

We’re here to help

We know reaching out can be hard. Call today to speak with one of our addiction recovery specialists. We will listen, learn, and offer support – without judgment. We welcome every person in need of support.